Milkshakes & Desserts

Our hand-spun milkshakes and rich, creamy malts are the best in Colorado! Made with extra-creamy Blue Bunny™ ice cream, every sip is smooth, flavorful, and downright irresistible.

Chocolate, Vanilla, Strawberry, Dreamy Orange Creamsicle, Banana, Chocolate, Cherry, The King (Banana & Peanut Butter), Brownie Fudge, Butterfinger®, Oreo®, M&M’s®, Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup®

1 mix-in. Additional mix-ins 50¢ each

Regular $7.50

Half-Size $5.50

Martin & Lewis

Smooth mix of vodka, coffee liqueur, and creamy ice cream that'll have you laughin’ and craving an encore — just like the iconic comedy duo

$11
The Janis Joplin

Soulful mix of bourbon, velvety vanilla ice cream, and a swirl of caramel that'll make you want to belt out a tune

$11
The Norman Bates

Dive into vanilla vodka, creamy ice cream, and a sinister drizzle of chocolate blood sauce

$11

Fruit Tart

Sweet & tangy fruit in a soft pastry crush, topped with a dash of light sugar glaze, whipped cream & caramel sauce

$7.15
Funnel Cake Fries

A shareable portion of funnel cake fries, topped with powdered sugar & your choice of chocolate or caramel sauce

$8.15
Banana Split

An American classic topped with chocolate, strawberries, and whipped cream. GF

$6.65
Classic Ice Cream Sundae

Hand-scooped ice cream topped with chocolate, caramel, or strawberry sauce & whipped cream. GF

$6.15
Toffee Cake

Buttery toffee topping over a mini bundt cake

$7.25

GF (Gluten Friendly Ingredients)

This menu consists of items prepared without gluten-containing ingredients based on information from our approved suppliers. Gunther Toody’s makes no claim that these items meet the definition of gluten-free, defined as containing less than 20 ppm of gluten per FDA standards. Because we have multiple sources of gluten in our kitchen, there is risk that gluten cross-contact may occur during the preparation and cooking of these items. Before placing your order please inform the manager of your food allergy and/or sensitivity so we can do everything possible to safely accommodate your dietary needs

*These items may be served raw or under-cooked or may contain ingredients that are raw or under-cooked. Consuming raw or under-cooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of food-borne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions

Milkshakes & Desserts